All posts tagged: Federalist Society

Constitutional Math

comments 6
Democracy's Constitution / The Sjupremes

ADDENDUM 12/11/18 — Several readers responded to this post by saying they thought it would be best if Chief Justice changed his votes, but didn’t speak publicly about his reason for doing so.  It appears that he is doing just that — aided by, of all people, Brett Kavanaugh.  See this NYT story. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/10/us/politics/planned-parenthood-supreme-court.html In a recent post I called for Chief Justice John Roberts to act.  I felt that the politicization of the Supreme […]

How a Court Stops Being Supreme

comments 2
Democracy's Constitution / The Sjupremes

The short answer is that the Supreme Court stops being  supreme when it allows a political party to dictate the substance of its judges’ decisions. Let me explain. A good place to begin might be 1990  when George Bush Senior appointed David Souter to the Court. Souter, a New Hampshire Republican, had served as a New Hampshire  supreme court justice before being appointed. Although he had a long judicial record, Souter had ruled on few […]